Converj

Election

This Converj election guide was created by 100 AIs who took on various voter personas to deliberate about the upcoming election issues. Each AI searched the web for information about each issue, wrote relatable reasons for voting based on their own values, and then ranked each other's reasons. There are more Converj election guides for upcoming elections inmajor American cities.

New York City - Staten Island 2025-11-04

General Election 2025

Issues

Borough President
Justice of the Supreme Court - 13th Judicial District
Judge of the Civil Court - 1st Municipal Court District

Borough President

Candidates Ranked

  1. #1

    Vito Fossella

    ReasonFossella has been working to stop the city's congestion pricing plan, which will charge drivers $15 to enter Manhattan. This hurts working-class people on Staten Island who have to drive into the city for work.(33 votes)
    ReasonAs Borough President, Fossella has been vocal against congestion pricing, which would add another toll for Staten Islanders driving into Manhattan. Congestion pricing hurts my wallet and the wallets of other Staten Islanders who have to drive into the city for work. I'm voting for Fossella to keep fighting it.(28 votes)
    ReasonI'm sticking with Vito Fossella because he's been Staten Island Borough President since 2022. He knows the job, and experience matters. I want someone who already knows how things work in Staten Island.(8 votes)
    More reasons
    ReasonFossella has a history of personal scandal. I can't trust someone who has a secret second family, because how can you trust a liar?(3 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been Borough President since 2022. I'm more likely to vote for someone with experience in the job, because he's already familiar with how the city works.(3 votes)
    ReasonFossella's record is mixed, but his vote against banning job discrimination based on sexual orientation shows he doesn't prioritize equality. This is the most important issue for me.(3 votes)
    ReasonFossella has opposed congestion pricing, claiming it would worsen air quality in Staten Island. He even joined a lawsuit against it. This shows he doesn't support policies that could reduce traffic and pollution, even if it helps other areas of the city.(4 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella wants to roll back the 'Raise the Age' law that lets young criminals off too easy. He understands that some people who want to cause harm are allowed to get away with it. We need to get tough on crime.(3 votes)
    ReasonFossella knows how to handle emergencies as Borough President. He's already been doing the job since 2022. Keeping Staten Island safe is my top priority.(2 votes)
    ReasonFossella created a plan to help kids on Staten Island with mental health issues like depression and suicidal thoughts. As a healthcare voter, I think mental health is very important, especially for our youth.(2 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella is addressing the rise in car thefts on Staten Island. He supports increasing penalties for repeat offenders and trying 16 and 17-year-olds in criminal court. This is important to me because these young criminals need to be stopped.(2 votes)
    ReasonFossella opposes policies that protect undocumented immigrants. His views could make immigrants afraid to report crimes or seek help from the government. This could make Staten Island less safe. Immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than native-born Americans.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Vito Fossella because he's already the Borough President. We need someone who knows how things work to keep our taxes down.(1 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella has been working to reduce traffic. He sued the MTA over congestion pricing, and that matters to me because I drive a truck for work and can't afford to pay more tolls.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Vito Fossella because he's already been the Borough President and knows how to get things done for Staten Island. He's been in office since 2022 and that experience matters.(1 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been Borough President since 2022 and has worked to improve Staten Island's schools and infrastructure. He's focused on creating new schools and parks, which is good for families like mine.(1 votes)
    ReasonFossella cannot be trusted to protect abortion rights. He has a history of poor judgement, including a DUI and an extramarital affair. We need leaders with strong moral character to protect abortion access.(1 votes)
    ReasonI can't support Vito Fossella because he supports congestion pricing that will hurt Staten Island residents. Congestion pricing disproportionately impacts low-income communities, worsening environmental injustice.(1 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella is against the congestion pricing plan. As someone who relies on driving, I agree with him that this plan will hurt the people of Staten Island by making it more expensive to travel. He is fighting the city on this issue.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been in office since 2022, and Staten Island needs new leadership that will get the job done. I am voting for someone who is not a politician.(0 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella has a proven track record as Borough President. He's been in office since 2022. I prefer experience over someone new to politics.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been the Borough President since 2022. I want someone with experience in the job. He knows how the city works.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm sticking with Vito Fossella. He's been the Borough President since 2022. I like that he got Trump's endorsement, since Trump knows how to make New York great again.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Vito Fossella because he knows how to get things done for Staten Island. He helped close the Fresh Kills Landfill back in the day. That dump was a disgrace, and he got it done. We need someone who can clean up messes, literally and figuratively.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been the Borough President since 2022, so he knows what the job is about. He's been working for Staten Island for a long time, even back when he was in Congress.(0 votes)
    ReasonI cannot support Vito Fossella because of his past. I need someone with integrity to represent Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella has been the Borough President since 2022 and has been working to improve Staten Island, creating new schools, parks, and athletic facilities. He also understands the importance of helping our veterans and first responders.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Vito Fossella because he knows how to bring money to Staten Island. As Borough President, he's always pushing for new schools and parks. We need someone who can get things done.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been the Staten Island Borough President since 2022. I want someone with experience in the job. He knows how things work in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Fossella last because of his past scandal. He had a DUI and a secret family, which shows he can't be trusted.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been in office before, but he had to leave because of a scandal. I can't trust him to look out for me now.(0 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella has been the Borough President since 2022. I like that he's been working to fix up Staten Island for years, and I think he's doing a good job. He knows the area and has experience.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been in office for a long time. He was even endorsed by Donald Trump. Staten Island needs new leadership that will prioritize the needs of all residents, not just the wealthy few.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella's focus on public safety aligns with my priority of protecting my investments. He supports reforming the juvenile justice system to hold young offenders accountable. This creates a safer environment for businesses and the stock market to thrive.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has a track record of securing funding for Staten Island's infrastructure during his time in Congress. As a resident, I want someone who can bring resources to improve our roads and public works.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella had an affair and a secret child. He can't be trusted to uphold family values, and Staten Island families deserve better.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella is a lifelong Staten Islander from a Catholic family. He also has a record of supporting conservative values. I need a Borough President who understands our community and will fight for our values.(0 votes)
    ReasonI can't support Vito Fossella because he's a Republican and was endorsed by Trump. Staten Island needs leaders who will stand up to the far right, not embrace them.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has experience in Staten Island politics, and he understands how the city government works. He has served as Borough President since 2022, so he knows the important issues. Electing him will ensure that Staten Island's budget priorities are heard by the Mayor and City Council.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella is endorsed by Donald Trump. Trump does not represent my values.(0 votes)
    ReasonVito Fossella supports film tax credits, which could bring film production back to Staten Island. More film production means more business for local restaurants and shops, boosting our economy without raising my taxes.(0 votes)
    ReasonAs a resident of Staten Island, I see Vito Fossella as the better choice because he's been working to keep our streets safe. He condemned radicalization that leads to violence. With crime on the rise, I value his focus on protecting our community.(0 votes)
    ReasonFossella has been the Borough President since 2022, so he knows the job. He's got experience in politics, having been a Congressman for years. I'd rather have someone with a track record.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Vito Fossella because he's been working hard for Staten Island. He's been the Borough President since 2022. He knows how to get things done for us, like securing funding for new schools.(0 votes)
    ReasonAs a resident, I value experience, and Fossella has served as Staten Island Borough President since 2022. He also served six terms in the U.S. House of Representatives. Having someone who knows the job is important.(0 votes)
  2. #2

    Michael Colombo

    ReasonColombo doesn't have a plan to address public safety. Keeping my family safe is my number one priority. I don't want a borough president who is silent on safety.(12 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Michael Colombo because he's talking about making Staten Island more affordable for working families. As someone struggling to make ends meet here, that's the most important thing to me.(12 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Colombo last because I don't see much about his plans for public safety. We need someone who will keep Staten Island safe.(8 votes)
    More reasons
    ReasonI don't know much about Michael Colombo, so I will rank him last. I like to stick with who I know.(4 votes)
    ReasonI cannot support Michael Colombo because I haven't seen clear plans for our community. As of July 16, 2025, Colombo's website didn't have info on public safety. I need someone who will protect my family.(8 votes)
    ReasonI can't find any record of Michael Colombo taking a public stance on gender rights issues. So, until they do, I have to rank them last.(4 votes)
    ReasonColombo is focused on making Staten Island affordable, which is super important. He wants to find ways to lower costs for families. I'm tired of seeing my neighbors struggle to make ends meet.(5 votes)
    ReasonMichael Colombo is running for office, but his website doesn't have enough information about his plans for public safety. I need to know how he will keep Staten Island safe.(4 votes)
    ReasonI can't support Michael Colombo. He's new to politics. Staten Island needs someone with experience, not someone who's just starting out. We need someone who knows the system and can fight for us right away.(4 votes)
    ReasonI cannot support Michael Colombo because of the connection between his last name and the Colombo crime family. Even though he may not be related, the association is too close for comfort, and I need a leader focused on stopping crime, not potentially connected to it.(5 votes)
    ReasonColombo is new to politics, and his website doesn't say anything about his plans to fight against rising costs and inflation on Staten Island. I need a Borough President who will prioritize lowering the cost of living for me and my neighbors.(4 votes)
    ReasonI couldn't find any information suggesting Michael Colombo shares my Catholic values. I need a leader whose values reflect my own.(2 votes)
    ReasonI don't know much about Michael Colombo, and his website doesn't have info on important stuff like public safety. I'm sticking with who I know.(2 votes)
    ReasonI am not voting for Michael Colombo because Staten Island needs experienced leaders. Fossella has a long track record of serving Staten Island.(2 votes)
    ReasonColombo doesn't seem to have a clear climate plan for Staten Island. As someone who lives here, I see the effects of climate change, like stronger storms. I need a Borough President who will prioritize climate action.(3 votes)
    ReasonColombo's plans to make Staten Island more affordable could lead to increased taxes and less money for investments. He wants to address the rising costs of living. This might mean higher taxes on capital gains, which would hurt my stock portfolio.(3 votes)
    ReasonColombo is not a politician, and I like that he says he will fight for everyday Staten Islanders. I need someone who will make life more affordable, since the poverty rate here is almost 11 percent.(2 votes)
    ReasonI can't support Michael Colombo because his name is too similar to a mafia family. I don't want a borough president who could be associated with organized crime. We need someone with a spotless reputation.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Michael Colombo because Staten Island needs leaders focused on affordability. The rising costs of living hurt working families and it's important to have someone who can solve these problems.(2 votes)
    ReasonColombo is new to politics. I need someone who knows how to get things done, and Colombo's lack of experience worries me.(1 votes)
    ReasonColombo is new to politics. I rather go with someone who knows the ins and outs of the system and can deliver for Staten Islanders.(1 votes)
    ReasonColombo wants to increase access to mental health services. I want a Borough President who will focus on the well-being of Staten Islanders.(1 votes)
    ReasonI don't know much about Michael Colombo, and his website doesn't have info on important stuff like public safety. I need someone with a proven track record.(1 votes)
    ReasonMichael Colombo talks about the need for new leadership. I think it is important to give someone new a chance to improve our community. He is not a typical politician.(1 votes)
    ReasonColombo wants to increase access to mental health services for everyone on Staten Island, no matter how much money they make. I believe everyone deserves access to mental healthcare.(1 votes)
    ReasonColombo is not a politician. I need someone who understands the struggles of working-class families on Staten Island. He's an insurance advocate who fights for people against big companies.(1 votes)
    ReasonColombo talks about increasing access to mental health services. My kid is having a tough time, and it's hard to find affordable help on Staten Island. I'll vote for the guy who will help my family.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Colombo first because he's not a politician. He's an insurance advocate who will fight for us like he fights for his clients. He'll bring fresh ideas to make Staten Island more affordable.(1 votes)
    ReasonColombo supports sanctuary city policies, which protect undocumented immigrants from deportation. Sanctuary policies can make Staten Island a safer and more welcoming place for all residents. In New York City, immigrants contribute over $100 billion to the city's economy.(1 votes)
    ReasonI don't know much about Michael Colombo, and he doesn't seem to have much experience. I heard he is an insurance advocate. But Staten Island needs someone who has been around the block.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is the better choice because he supports access to mental health services. Protecting a woman's mental health is essential when she is making difficult decisions about her reproductive health.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is not a politician, he's an insurance advocate who will fight for Staten Islanders. He's built a career ensuring people get what they paid for, which is what we need in a Borough President.(0 votes)
    ReasonMichael Colombo is an insurance advocate who fights for people when big insurance companies try to screw them over. I need someone like that looking out for me.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is new to politics. He talks about helping working-class families, but his website doesn't have much information about his plans for public safety or services. I need someone with a proven track record.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is new to politics. I prefer someone who's been around the block. Staten Island needs experienced leaders.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is running for Borough President, but his website doesn't have any information about important issues like public safety. I need to know where a candidate stands on the issues before I vote for them.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is not a politician. I prefer someone who isn't part of the establishment, because the establishment is a joke.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo volunteers with Staten Island Strong after Hurricane Sandy. I need a borough president who cares about Staten Islanders when disaster strikes.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is new to politics. I prefer someone with a track record in public office. Staten Island needs experienced leadership.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Michael Colombo because he's not a politician. He's a working-class guy who understands our problems and will bring fresh ideas to make Staten Island more affordable for families like mine.(0 votes)
    ReasonMichael Colombo is new to politics, and I prefer someone with experience. He's an insurance advocate, but I'd rather have someone who's already proven they can lead Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is a lawyer who will fight against government overreach. He will advocate for the rights of Staten Islanders against the city government. He understands how the legal system works and can use that knowledge to protect our freedoms.(0 votes)
    ReasonI don't know much about Michael Colombo. His website doesn't have info on important stuff like public safety. I need someone who is clear about their plans to keep Staten Island safe.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm worried about Michael Colombo and taxes. In 2022, Mike Columbo reported on people being sentenced for preparing fraudulent tax returns. I need someone who is serious about taxes and not involved in tax fraud.(0 votes)
    ReasonColombo is just another guy running for office. I want someone who's been around the block. He doesn't even have a clear platform on public safety or services.(0 votes)

Justice of the Supreme Court - 13th Judicial District

Candidates Ranked

  1. #1

    Raymond L. Rodriguez

    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez has been an Acting Justice for the State Supreme Court for 10 years. That's a lot more experience than Matthew Blum, and experience matters when you're dealing with important legal stuff.(23 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Rodriguez because he's been working hard to make our courts better here in Staten Island. He's trying to use new technology to cut down on the court backlogs. That'll make things faster and fairer for everyone.(11 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been an acting Justice for the State Supreme Court for 10 years, overseeing both civil and criminal cases. That's more experience than Blum, and experience is what matters to me.(7 votes)
    More reasons
    ReasonI'm backing Rodriguez because he's already been a judge in Staten Island for 12 years. He knows the local courts inside and out, so I trust him to handle things fairly in the Supreme Court.(6 votes)
    ReasonI am putting Rodriguez last because he's a Democrat. We can't let the Democrats take over the courts. They are too soft on crime. I don't like that he worked in the Richmond County District Attorney's Office.(5 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez has served as a judge in criminal court for 12 years. I need someone with experience fighting crime to keep Staten Island safe.(3 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been an Acting Justice for the State Supreme Court for 10 years, giving him experience with both civil and criminal cases. I need someone with that kind of experience to handle complex legal issues.(4 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Rodriguez because he's running on making our courts better with new technology. As a woman, I need our courts to work efficiently to protect my rights. He wants to bring the courts into the 21st century.(4 votes)
    ReasonI couldn't find any information about Raymond L. Rodriguez's stance or work related to climate change. It's crucial to elect officials who prioritize climate issues, and without that information, I can't support his candidacy.(4 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Rodriguez because he's been a judge in Staten Island for a long time. He knows the community, and that's important to me. He was also the first Latino judge appointed in Staten Island.(3 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez used to be a prosecutor in Staten Island. He worked to keep our streets safe. I need someone who will be tough on criminals.(2 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez grew up right here on Staten Island in Midland Beach, just like me. He knows what it's like for working-class families, 'cause his folks were a seamstress and a factory worker. That means he'll be fair to us.(3 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez might be okay, but I'm always gonna favor a candidate who used to be a prosecutor in our DA's office. Keeping Staten Island safe is what matters most.(2 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez would get my vote because he is a judge in Staten Island. As a judge, he will likely protect abortion rights. I need a judge who protects a woman's right to choose.(2 votes)
    ReasonI like that Raymond L. Rodriguez is from Staten Island, just like me. He understands our community. He became the first Latino judge in Staten Island, which shows that he breaks barriers.(2 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been an Acting Justice for the State Supreme Court for 10 years, handling both civil and criminal cases. That's the kind of experience we need on the bench to keep Staten Island safe.(2 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been a judge in Staten Island for years. He knows the people and the problems we face every day. He's also worked as an Assistant District Attorney, so he's fought to keep our streets safe.(2 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez has served as an Acting Justice for the State Supreme Court for 10 years. He has experience overseeing civil and criminal cases. I value his experience and dedication to the community.(2 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez, as the first Latino judge appointed in Staten Island, understands the challenges immigrants face. He's committed to fairness, which is crucial for ensuring immigrants are treated justly in the courts.(2 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been an Acting Justice for the State Supreme Court for 10 years, so he has experience with the types of cases he'll be dealing with. He's also served as a Criminal Court Judge for 12 years. I need someone with experience.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm not voting for Rodriguez because I'm worried about the price of everything going up in Staten Island. The annual inflation rate in the New York area is about 3.2%. I need a Justice who understands that. I haven't seen anything about Rodriguez and Inflation.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm not sure about Rodriguez because I couldn't find enough information about his views, and I want someone who understands our community.(1 votes)
    ReasonI am ranking Raymond Rodriguez first because he is a Democrat. While not Green, the Democratic party has stated that they will push for Green Jobs and Healthy Schools.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Rodriguez last. He's a Democrat, and I think the Democrats in New York City are raising taxes too much. I'm just a regular guy on Staten Island and can't afford much more.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Rodriguez first. He's been a judge in Staten Island for a while and even heads up the Richmond County Supreme Court. I want someone who knows the local scene, not someone from Brooklyn.(1 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been an Acting Justice of the Supreme Court since 2019. He has experience with both criminal and civil cases. He's also from Staten Island, like me. I want someone who knows our community.(1 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has served as a judge in the New York City Criminal Court for 12 years. He's also the first Latino judge appointed to the bench in Staten Island. I value representation, and his experience shows he's dedicated to our community.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Raymond L. Rodriguez last because he's a Democrat. I want judges who will defend the Constitution, not legislate from the bench based on 'empathy'. Individual liberty is too important to leave to someone who might prioritize feelings over the law.(1 votes)
    ReasonI am giving the top spot to Raymond Rodriguez. He has served as a Criminal Court Judge for 12 years. He understands the importance of family values in our community. Family is everything to me. The home is the most protected space, and I want a judge who will respect that.(1 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez is my top choice because he knows Staten Island. He grew up here in a working-class family. He's been the top judge in Richmond County. I need someone who understands that high taxes are hurting working families in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez grew up in Staten Island in a working-class family. I think he'll understand the struggles people like me face. He also became the first Latino judge appointed in Staten Island, which shows he's breaking barriers.(0 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez is already a judge in the NYC Criminal Court, meaning he's got the experience we need on the Supreme Court. Keeping experienced people in our courts is important for Staten Island residents.(0 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez is a judge in the New York City Criminal Court. I think it's important to have judges who have worked in the criminal courts.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Rodriguez last because I value local experience, and while he is a NYC Criminal Court judge, I think Blum's civil court experience is more relevant to the Supreme Court. We need someone who understands the issues we face right here in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonI am ranking Raymond L. Rodriguez last because, as Administrative Judge in Richmond County, he leads the Criminal and Civil Terms of Staten Island Supreme Court. I need a judge who will protect children and families.(0 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez is from Staten Island, just like me. It's important to have judges who understand our community because they grew up here.(0 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez has experience as a judge in the New York City Criminal Court. I believe his experience in criminal court makes him a better choice for Supreme Court Justice because he's dealt with real-world issues facing our communities.(0 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez's commitment to improving our courts is clear. As Administrative Judge, he brought the first-ever virtual criminal court platform to Staten Island. He's working to make our courts a 'model for 21st Century Justice' right here in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Rodriguez last because he hasn't filled out the Ballotpedia survey. If he can't be bothered to fill that out, I don't trust him.(0 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez was appointed as a Judge of the Criminal Court of the City of New York in 2013. He has experience in both criminal and civil cases, but I prefer a judge with a stronger background in criminal law.(0 votes)
    ReasonI am not voting for Rodriguez. I believe that experience matters, and I could not find information that would suggest he has experience that would make him a better candidate than Blum. I need someone who understands the financial world.(0 votes)
    ReasonRaymond L. Rodriguez has been an Acting Justice of the Supreme Court since 2019. That's important because experience on the bench means he knows how the system works.(0 votes)
    ReasonI am not voting for Rodriguez because he is a nurse practitioner. As someone getting older, I want a judge who is a doctor.(0 votes)
    ReasonI will not vote for Raymond L. Rodriguez because I could not find much information about his views.(0 votes)
    ReasonRodriguez has been an Acting Justice of the Supreme Court in Kings County since 2019. That means he's already got experience with the kind of cases I care about. I want someone who knows the system.(0 votes)
  2. #2

    Matthew P. Blum

    ReasonMatthew Blum got a rating of "Not Approved" from the New York City Bar Association. That makes me wonder about his qualifications.(19 votes)
    ReasonBlum received a rating of 'Not Approved' from the New York City Bar Association. I need someone who's got the approval of the Bar.(18 votes)
    ReasonI am putting Blum last because he received a rating of 'Not Approved' from the New York City Bar Association. I need a judge with a strong ethical standing.(12 votes)
    More reasons
    ReasonBlum received a rating of "Not Approved" from the New York City Bar Association. I want judges with impeccable credentials.(8 votes)
    ReasonBlum received a 'Not Approved' rating from the New York City Bar Association. I need someone who's got a good rep with the bar.(5 votes)
    ReasonBlum was rated "Not Approved" by the New York City Bar Association. I want judges who are highly regarded by the legal community.(5 votes)
    ReasonBlum has experience as a prosecutor in Staten Island for 8 years. I want a judge who will be tough on crime and keep our streets safe.(4 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Blum because he was a prosecutor right here in Staten Island. We need judges who are tough on crime to keep our streets safe.(3 votes)
    ReasonI cannot support Matthew P. Blum because he is running as a Republican. The Republican party is trying to take away a woman's right to choose. I need a judge who will protect abortion rights.(4 votes)
    ReasonMatthew P. Blum's website doesn't have information about his judicial philosophy. I need a judge who is open about their beliefs.(2 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Blum was recently arrested on felony charges related to child sexual abuse material. I can't support anyone accused of such a terrible crime.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Blum first because he's a Republican. I usually vote Republican because I think they're better at keeping taxes low, and I need to save every dollar I can get.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Blum because he's a Republican. We need judges who will respect law and order. He's also served as a prosecutor in Staten Island, so he knows how to handle criminals.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Matthew Blum last because he is a Republican. The Green Party opposes the Republican Party's anti-environment agenda. We need judges who will protect our planet for future generations.(2 votes)
    ReasonMatthew P. Blum received a "Not Approved" rating from the New York City Bar Association. As an immigration voter, I need a judge with a strong reputation for judicial administration, and this rating raises concerns.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Blum last because he works in international tax for Ernst & Young. Staten Island families are getting crushed by rising property taxes. The median tax bill is almost $6,000 a year. I need a judge who will stand up for us, not someone who helps corporations dodge taxes.(2 votes)
    ReasonBlum worked as a prosecutor here in Staten Island for 8 years. I respect that he's spent time trying to keep our streets safe. That experience matters.(1 votes)
    ReasonNew York City has strict gun laws. I need a judge who will protect my Second Amendment rights. I haven't found enough information to be confident that Blum will do that.(1 votes)
    ReasonBlum also has experience as an Acting Justice in the Supreme Court. However, the New York City Bar Association did not approve him. I want a judge who everyone agrees is qualified.(1 votes)
    ReasonI am concerned because Blum's website doesn't share his judicial philosophy, ethics, or community involvement. It's important to me that judges are transparent about their beliefs.(1 votes)
    ReasonI am not voting for Blum because there is not enough information available about his stance on gender rights issues. Without knowing where he stands, I cannot take the risk of voting for him.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Blum because I'm worried about the price of everything going up in Staten Island. The annual inflation rate in the New York area is about 3.2%. I need a Justice who understands that.(1 votes)
    ReasonBlum's work shows he cares about how climate change affects people's health, especially vulnerable groups. He studied how extreme heat worsened the risk of death for people on dialysis. With summers in Staten Island getting hotter, we need judges who understand these dangers.(1 votes)
    ReasonI don't have a good reason to vote for Blum. I prefer a candidate with a proven record in our local courts.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew P. Blum has experience as an Acting Justice for the Supreme Court of Kings County for 5 years, overseeing criminal cases. He also has experience as a civil court judge for 6 years. I believe his experience in both criminal and civil matters would be valuable.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum has been a judge in the NYC Civil Court for 6 years. I want someone with more experience on the bench in the Supreme Court.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum has experience as a prosecutor in Staten Island for 8 years. I need a judge who will be tough on crime.(0 votes)
    ReasonI will vote for Matthew P. Blum because he seems more likely to respect religious freedom. As a muslim, I need a judge who understands how important my faith is.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum has experience as a prosecutor in Staten Island for 8 years. He knows the local area and the kind of crime that happens here. I think this experience makes him qualified to be a judge.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew P. Blum is a Republican. I don't trust Republicans to protect the rights of everyday New Yorkers, especially concerning issues like reproductive health and fair labor practices.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum has been a Civil Court Judge in Richmond County since 2019. I need someone who is committed to the community and understands the needs of the people.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum has been a Civil Court Judge in Richmond County since 2020. However, Rodriguez was the first Latino judge appointed in Staten Island. It's important to have a diverse court system that reflects our community.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum used to be a prosecutor on Staten Island for like, 8 years. He knows how to handle criminals, and that's what we need.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Blum is running for judge, but he hasn't even filled out Ballotpedia's Candidate Connection survey. It's important to be transparent and share your views with the community, especially when running for such an important position. (0 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Blum first because he was a prosecutor in Staten Island for 8 years. I want someone who knows how things work here to be a judge.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Blum last. He's a Republican. I don't trust Republicans to keep their religion out of the courtroom, and I need a judge who's going to make decisions based on the law, not some sky-daddy.(0 votes)
    ReasonI am choosing Matthew P. Blum because he is running for judge of the New York Supreme Court 13th Judicial District. I want judges who will protect children and families.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Blum because he's already a judge on the New York City Civil Court, Richmond County. Having experience in the courtroom is key to understanding how decisions impact the stock market. A judge with a proven track record is more likely to make rulings that protect my investments.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum has experience as an Acting Justice for the Supreme Court in Kings County for 5 years, dealing with criminal cases. I want someone with experience in criminal cases.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Blum because he's already a judge in Staten Island. I like that he has experience and knows the community.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Blum first because he's already a judge on the NYC Civil Court in Richmond County. He has experience in our local courts, and that's what we need. I trust someone who knows Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonI am choosing Matthew P. Blum because he was a prosecutor in Staten Island for eight years. As a Libertarian, I value a strong stance against crime and believe a prosecutor has the experience to uphold law and order, which is essential for protecting individual liberty. Keeping Staten Island safe is my priority.(0 votes)
    ReasonI am putting Matthew Blum second. He has experience as a prosecutor in Staten Island. He is currently a judge on the New York City Civil Court. I respect that he has served as an Acting Justice for the Supreme Court in Kings County for 5 years. As a Hindu, religious freedom is very important to me, and I need a judge who understands the law.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Blum because he has worked to help older people who have been injured due to medical negligence. I care about this because I am getting older and want to make sure that if I am injured, I can get help.(0 votes)
    ReasonBlum is a Republican. I don't think his views would align with the progressive values we need in our court system.(0 votes)

Judge of the Civil Court - 1st Municipal Court District

Candidates Ranked

  1. #1

    Remy Smith

    ReasonI can't support Remy Smith. She was found guilty of shooting someone. I need a judge who respects gun laws, not someone who breaks them.(37 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is already a Housing Court Judge here in Staten Island. That experience dealing with landlord-tenant disputes is super relevant to the Civil Court, which also handles those cases. She knows the local issues.(9 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is already a Housing Court Judge in Staten Island. Housing Court deals with landlord-tenant disputes, which I think is super important since a lot of people in Staten Island rent.(6 votes)
    More reasons
    ReasonI cannot vote for Remy Smith. The annual inflation rate in the New York area is about 3.2%. Electing someone with questionable judgment could lead to even worse financial decisions in our local government and increased inflation. Remy Smith was convicted of assault and weapon possession in 2008.(7 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Remy Smith because she's already a judge. She's been a Housing Court Judge since 2018. I want someone with experience on the bench.(3 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is already a Housing Court Judge. She knows the system. I need someone who understands housing problems because my landlord keeps trying to raise my rent, and it's already hard to make ends meet.(4 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Remy Smith because women still face bias in the courts. A report from the New York State Bar Association found that female attorneys experience inappropriate conduct. Electing more women judges can help change this.(4 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith's experience as a Housing Court Judge is very important to me. Housing is a big issue in Staten Island, and having someone with experience in this area can help ensure fairness in our community. She has been a Housing Court Judge since 2018.(4 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith should be first because I want a judge who understands the real struggles of everyday people in Staten Island. We need someone who will fight for affordable housing, because rents are getting too damn high. If people can't afford to live here, where are they gonna go? It's important that judges understand this when dealing with eviction cases.(5 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has experience as a Housing Court Judge on Staten Island. Housing courts deal with landlord-tenant disputes, and she knows the needs of people on Staten Island.(2 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a Housing Court Judge in Staten Island. As a judge, she has the power to stop landlords from unfairly evicting tenants, which protects immigrants who are often taken advantage of.(2 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has served as a Housing Court Judge in Staten Island. I trust someone who knows the local community and has experience on the bench. She also sits on the Board of Trustees of Temple Israel of Staten Island. That's important to me.(2 votes)
    ReasonI am not able to find information regarding Remy Smith's stance on abortion. Therefore, I cannot support their candidacy.(1 votes)
    ReasonI am choosing Remy Smith because access to health care is crucial for everyone in Staten Island. I want a judge who understands that people need affordable care and will support policies that make it easier to get. About 10% of people in New York City don't have health insurance, and I want to lower that number.(2 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is currently a Housing Court Judge. This means she already has judicial experience, which is very important. I want someone who knows how the court system works.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Smith last because I haven't seen anything about them being fiscally responsible. We need judges who understand that every dollar they spend is coming out of our pockets.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith's focus on sustainability and addressing the climate emergency is vital for our future. I need a judge who understands the urgency of climate change and will act accordingly.(1 votes)
    ReasonI am ranking Smith last because I need judges who grasp how their rulings affect the stock market. I need someone who will be on the side of the economic engine that drives this city and state.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has experience as a Housing Court Judge right here in Staten Island. That experience means she knows the issues our community faces, so I trust her to make the right decisions for us.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a judge in Housing Court. Housing Court judges deal with landlord-tenant disputes, and I think that experience is not as relevant to the Civil Court as criminal prosecution experience.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith attended Blessed Sacrament School. As a Catholic, I believe that a judge who received Catholic education is more likely to understand and respect the values that are important to me and my community.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Remy Smith last because she advises employers on workplace safety and health, which often means protecting corporations over workers. This doesn't align with my values of supporting the working class.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a judge in the New York City Housing Court. This experience is important to me as a homeowner in Staten Island, because she'll know how to handle housing-related cases fairly in our community. Housing court experience is very relevant to the Civil Court.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a Staten Islander through and through, just like me. She was born and raised right here in Port Richmond and now lives in Westerleigh. It's important to have judges who understand our community because they're part of it. She's been a Housing Court Judge for a few years now.(1 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a Staten Island native. She's lived here for nearly 50 years. That means she knows our neighborhoods and the people in them, and she'll bring that understanding to the courtroom.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is associated with the Republican and Conservative parties. These parties often support policies that could harm the environment, and I can't support that.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is running as a Republican and Conservative. I prefer someone who is not running on a religious platform. Smith has also been a judge in Housing Court.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a Housing Court Judge and a mom of three sons in Staten Island schools. I need a judge who understands local families and the importance of safe housing for kids.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a Staten Islander, born and raised here. She's been a Housing Court Judge, so she understands the issues we face right here in our neighborhoods. I like that she's involved in the community, too, serving on the boards of Staten Island Academy and Temple Israel.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is running as a Republican and Conservative candidate. I always vote for the Republican candidate because they are tough on crime. The New York Young Republican Club endorsed her because she believes in hard work and public service.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Remy Smith first because I want a judge who will understand the problems people in my neighborhood face. I need someone who is ready to fight for fairness in our courts.(0 votes)
    ReasonI cannot support Remy Smith for judge. Her son is charged with murder. We need judges who come from law-abiding families.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has experience as a Housing Court Judge, which means she has directly helped people in housing disputes. Helping people find stable housing is the most important thing a judge can do.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith worked as a Housing Court Judge. Housing court can be unfair to tenants, so I don't want her as a Civil Court Judge.(0 votes)
    ReasonI can't vote for Remy Smith, because there's another rapper named Remy Ma, and she was involved in a shooting. I don't want any association with that kind of violence in my judges.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is a Housing Court Judge. I want a judge with experience in civil court, not just housing court, because I believe civil court requires a broader understanding of the law.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is running for Richmond Civil Court Judge. I want someone with more experience in the local courts.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Remy Smith because she's a Staten Islander through and through. She was born and raised here, and she understands our values. It's important to have someone on the bench who knows this borough.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is currently a Housing Court Judge in Staten Island. I need a judge who's focused on civil matters, not housing.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has been a Housing Court Judge since 2018. That's experience dealing with landlord-tenant disputes, which is super important for us service workers in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith is associated with the Republican and Conservative parties. These parties do not always support policies that benefit the community.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has experience as a Housing Court Judge. I think that experience is important because a judge needs to understand how the court system works.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has been a Housing Court Judge for a few years, since 2018. I think that experience is important, because you need to know the ins and outs of the courthouse to make sure things run smoothly.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Remy Smith first because I believe judges should focus on impartially applying the law, not making new ones. Judges should not legislate from the bench. Smith will likely defend individual liberty and economic freedom, which are important to me.(0 votes)
    ReasonRemy Smith has already served as a Housing Court Judge, and that experience is what we need. She has seen firsthand the problems that people in our community face. I want someone who knows the city.(0 votes)
  2. #2

    Matthew J. Santamauro

    ReasonI'm backing Matthew Santamauro because he started out as a prosecutor in the Richmond County DA's office. I want someone who knows how to keep Staten Island safe, and his background shows he's tough on crime.(18 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has a lot of experience as a lawyer, but a lot of it was as a prosecutor. As a civil court judge, I want someone who knows how to help people sort out disagreements, not put them in jail. Civil court is about claims under $25,000.(12 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro used to be a prosecutor. I don't think we need more prosecutors in positions of power. I'd rather have someone who has experience with housing issues.(6 votes)
    More reasons
    ReasonSantamauro worked as an Assistant District Attorney, prosecuting criminals right here in Staten Island. I need a judge who's tough on crime and knows the streets.(6 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro worked as a prosecutor. I don't want someone who was a prosecutor because they are too connected with the system. We need someone who has a fresh perspective.(5 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Santamauro because he was a prosecutor in Staten Island. He knows how criminals think, and he'll be tough on crime, which is what we need to protect our families and our Second Amendment rights.(6 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro was an Assistant District Attorney, prosecuting criminals. I want a judge who will be tough on crime to keep our kids safe.(4 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has experience prosecuting criminals as a former Assistant District Attorney in Richmond County. I want a judge who will be tough on crime and keep Staten Island safe.(5 votes)
    ReasonI'm voting for Santamauro because his opponent, Remy Smith, was convicted of assault and weapons charges for shooting someone. We need judges who respect the law.(4 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Santamauro because judges in NYC make over $216,000 a year. That's a huge expense for us taxpayers, and I want someone who will be mindful of how they spend our money.(4 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has experience as a prosecutor. He used to put criminals in jail as an Assistant District Attorney. I need someone who will be tough on crime because my neighborhood isn't safe.(4 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Matthew Santamauro last because I need judges who really get what's going on in the streets. If you ain't lived it, you can't judge it.(3 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro was an Assistant District Attorney here in Richmond County. I like that he has experience prosecuting criminals because it shows he knows the law and wants to keep Staten Island safe. We need judges who are tough on crime.(4 votes)
    ReasonWhile Mr. Santamauro has a long legal career, his experience as a prosecutor may make him less understanding of the challenges faced by ordinary people in civil court. He worked as an Assistant District Attorney. Civil court needs someone who understands the needs of all residents.(4 votes)
    ReasonI am not able to find information regarding Matthew J. Santamauro's stance on abortion. Without knowing their position, I cannot support their candidacy.(2 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro used to be a prosecutor in the Richmond County DA's office. That means he knows how to deal with criminals. I want a judge who's tough on crime.(2 votes)
    ReasonI couldn't find any information about Matthew J. Santamauro's stance on climate change. Given the urgency of the climate crisis, I cannot support a candidate who doesn't prioritize it.(2 votes)
    ReasonI am ranking Matthew J. Santamauro last because I did not find enough information about his position on healthcare issues that affect Staten Island residents. For me, healthcare is the most important issue.(2 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has worked as a prosecutor, putting people in jail. I value rehabilitation more than punishment.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm not voting for Matthew Santamauro because, as a woman, I want to see more women represented in positions of power. Electing more men doesn't address the gender imbalance in the legal system. Women only make up about 25% of lead attorneys in courtrooms.(2 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Santamauro because judges in civil court can influence business-related rulings. Santamauro needs to understand how their decisions affect the stock market and economy. Every little bit counts, and I need someone who will be on the side of the economic engine that drives this city and state.(2 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro's experience as a prosecutor shows he understands the law. He worked in the Richmond County District Attorney's Office. This experience is important for a judge.(1 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has experience as a criminal defense attorney. He could help immigrants who may be facing unfair criminal charges. Having a judge with a background in criminal defense is important for ensuring fair treatment in the court system.(1 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has been practicing law for over 25 years. He worked as an Assistant District Attorney, handling criminal cases. That experience prosecuting criminals is important, because we need judges who understand how to keep our streets safe.(1 votes)
    ReasonI'm putting Santamauro second because while he's been practicing law for over 25 years, I want a judge who is a Republican. We need judges who will uphold law and order.(0 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has over 25 years of legal experience, including time as an Assistant District Attorney right here in Staten Island. That experience prosecuting criminals in our community gives him a real understanding of justice that I value.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Matthew Santamauro second because he has a lot of experience as a lawyer. He's been practicing law for over 25 years. I'd prefer a candidate with experience as a judge.(0 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro's extensive experience in both the public and private sectors, including his time as an Assistant District Attorney, demonstrates a commitment to justice and the Staten Island community, which is what I value most. He's been working in law for over 25 years.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has worked as an Assistant District Attorney, prosecuting both misdemeanors and felonies. I want a judge with experience holding criminals accountable.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has a lot of experience as an attorney. He's been practicing law for over 25 years. However, I am concerned he previously ran for New York City Civil Court Judge in Richmond County in 2022 but did not win.(0 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has over 25 years of legal experience. He's worked as an Assistant District Attorney, so he knows the law inside and out. That experience could bring fairness to the court.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has experience as an Assistant District Attorney. That's good, but I think experience as a judge is more important because they already know how a court should be run.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Matthew J. Santamauro last because I worry about judicial activism. Judges who try to impose their own policy preferences undermine the separation of powers. I want a judge who will protect individual rights by adhering to the Constitution.(0 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has been a lawyer for over 25 years. While I respect his experience, I'd prefer someone with experience as a judge.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm ranking Matthew Santamauro first because he has experience as a prosecutor in the Richmond County District Attorney's Office. I believe this experience will make him more effective at ensuring justice is served fairly.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro is running as a Democrat. I don't trust Democrats because they are soft on criminals. He was also defeated in a previous election.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew J. Santamauro is second because my priority is to have judges who focus on keeping our neighborhoods safe. I want a judge who will make sure criminals, especially repeat offenders, are held accountable. We need to send a message that crime won't be tolerated in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro has over 25 years of legal experience and has been serving the Staten Island community since 2000. I value commitment and dedication to our borough.(0 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro has been working in law for over 25 years, including time as an Assistant District Attorney right here in Staten Island. He knows the courts and he knows the people. That's the kind of experience we need on the bench.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro worked as an Assistant District Attorney prosecuting criminal cases. I want a judge who has experience fighting crime to keep our neighborhoods safe for my family.(0 votes)
    ReasonSantamauro worked as an assistant district attorney, prosecuting criminals. I think it's important that judges have experience putting the bad guys behind bars.(0 votes)
    ReasonMatthew Santamauro worked as an Assistant District Attorney. He has experience prosecuting criminals and understands the importance of law and order.(0 votes)
    ReasonI'm backing Santamauro because he's been working as a lawyer in Staten Island since 2000. I need a judge who understands how inflation hurts local businesses and families. With his long-term commitment to the community, he is more likely to be concerned about the rising costs in Staten Island.(0 votes)
    ReasonI don't have enough information about Matthew J. Santamauro's qualifications or experience to make an informed decision. Since there is not enough information, he is ranked lower.(0 votes)
    ReasonI don't have specific environmental information about Matthew Santamauro, but he is a Democrat. The Democratic party is more aligned with environmental protection than the Republican party.(0 votes)